COLLEGE FINANCIAL AID

Students who receive above-average scores on standardized college admissions tests, such as the SAT, may benefit the most from commercial test preparation services, according to new report from the National Association for College Admission Counseling, although the benefits of such test preparation may not outweigh the costs for many families (“Test Preparation May Help High Scorers Most, Report Says,” The Chronicle of Higher Education, May 20, 2009).

Research indicates that commercial test preparation services may raise students’ SAT scores by up to 30 points, however the score gains may not be directly attributable to the coaching alone, says author of the NACAC report Derek Briggs, associate professor of education at the University of Colorado at Boulder.

In his report, “Preparation for College Admission Exams,” Briggs suggests that students who don’t use test prep services may still be able to achieve the same range of score increases seen by those students who do use the services just by purchasing a test preparation handbook and taking a series of practice tests.

“If there are effects to be gained through preparation,” Briggs said, “can you get the same effect without spending the money? That’s a pertinent question in this economy.”



Does Test Prep Coaching Improve Admissions Chances?

Of all the colleges Briggs surveyed in his study, only one third said that in some cases an increase of 20 points on the math portion of the SAT or an increase of 10 points on the critical-reading section could “significantly improve” an applicant’s chance of being admitted. This was especially true, the report indicated, at highly selective colleges where applicant scores tend to fall within a narrow range.

“If you come from a wealthy family and have high scores to begin with and can spend $1,000, then test prep might be worth it for those 30 points,” Briggs said. “What’s unfortunate is if middle- class or poorer families think test prep is going to raise their scores by 300 points. If you’re a kid with scores between 400 to 500, I’m not sure it’s going to make any difference.”

Seppy Basili, a vice president at Kaplan Test Prep and Admissions, is concerned what effect Brigg’s findings might have on test takers, especially black and Hispanic students who typically don’t score as high as white students on the SAT.

Basili said, “I wouldn’t want the message to minority students to be that you can’t benefit by preparing.”